Spring 2019 (33.1) Essay

Conflicting Norms, Values, and Interests: A Perspective from Legal Academia

Abstract: The analytical tension between legal norms, moral values, and national interests seems no uncharted territory in political science, but has found very little interest in legal academia. For lawyers, moral values and national interests are largely “unknowns,” dealt with by other disciplines. Looking a bit deeper, the picture becomes more nuanced, however. As part of a roundtable on "Balancing Legal Norms, Moral Values, and National Interests," this essay argues that norms, values, and interests are not different universes of legal normativity, morality, and specific interests, but are interrelated concepts. Values clearly influence norms and often underpin them, while seemingly concrete norms (rules) are themselves often fragile constructs trying to balance competing interests. Value systems are quite diverse within societies, and this is even truer for interests; each society is a dynamic system of social interaction where conflicting interests are constantly playing out. In a way, underlying conflicts of values and interests are constantly being renegotiated in the legal system, with the norms enshrined in the text of statutes and treaties serving to constitute transitory reference points.

Keywords: legal norms, moral values, national interests, legal academia, constructivism

A full version of this essay is available to subscribers only. Click here for access.

More in this issue

Spring 2019 (33.1) Response

Could a United Nations Code of Conduct Help Curb Atrocities? A Response to Bolarinwa Adediran

Although a UN code of conduct may have little effect on Security Council decision-making, the proposals have already proven their worth in political and normative ...

Spring 2019 (33.1) Review Essay

The Many Evils of Inequality: An Examination of T. M. Scanlon’s Pluralist Account

This review essay presents an in-depth theoretical look at—and critique of—Scanlon’s pluralist approach to objectionable inequality.

Spring 2019 (33.1) Essay

Humanitarian Diplomacy: The ICRC’s Neutral and Impartial Advocacy in Armed Conflicts

This essay argues that there is an important place for the ICRC’s style of “quiet” diplomacy alongside other “loud” forms of advocacy.