Fall 2010 (24.3) Feature

Kicking Bodies and Damning Souls: The Danger of Harming "Innocent" Individuals While Punishing "Delinquent" States

It is both possible and important to talk about institutions, in the sense of formal organizations, as moral agents in world politics. As moral agents, institutions can be assigned duties. They can also be blamed for failing to discharge them. But how can we respond to this type of failure? Punishment is a prominent and problematic response to institutional delinquency.

This article explores three potential problems with any attempt to punish an institution at the corporate level, each of which focuses on what such an attempt risks doing to the institution's individual human constituents. I label these potential problems ''guilt by association,'' ''misdirected harm'' and ''overspill.'' I illustrate each by turning to the danger of harming ''innocent'' individuals while ostensibly punishing ''delinquent'' states through organized violence, drawing on examples of discrepancies between the justifications for punitive action and the ultimate objects of harm in the recent wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

In conclusion, I argue that particular forms of punishment cannot represent morally coherent responses to culpability that is located at the corporate level of an institution. Punitive war waged against the ''delinquent'' state, when responsibility for harm and wrongdoing is not distributive amongst its individual members, provides an extreme and consequential case of such incoherence.

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.

More in this issue

Fall 2010 (24.3) Review

Briefly Noted

This section contains a round-up of recent notable books in the field of international affairs.

Fall 2010 (24.3) Feature

The Ethical Implications of Sea-Level Rise Due to Climate Change

Does humanity have a moral obligation toward the estimated millions of individuals who will be displaced from their homes over the course of this century ...

Fall 2010 (24.3) Feature

Reviving Nuclear Ethics: A Renewed Research Agenda for the Twenty-First Century

Since the end of the Cold War, international ethicists have focused largely on issues outside the traditional scope of security studies. The nuclear ethics literature ...