Winter 2013 (27.4) Essay

Muslim Discourse on Rebellion

Within Islamic thought, the judgments pertaining to rebels constitute a subset of the larger category of “judgments pertaining to armed struggle” (ahkam al-jihad). Indeed, one might refer to the latter as the overarching name for a Muslim war convention, which would then include judgments pertaining to military actions intended to: (a) extend or enhance the territory in which Islam provides governance or serves as the established religion of state; (b) defend the Islamic territory against invaders; and (c) regulate the relations between various groups within the territory of Islam, including (i) ahl al-dhimma, the “protected” class of non-Muslims (Christians, Jews, and others), (ii) apostates (Muslims who stand accused of abandoning Islam), (iii) highwaymen and other renegades, and (iv) secessionists and rebels (ahl al-khawarij wa al-bughat).

As we consider Muslim discourse about rebellion, it is worth summarizing some of the salient features of this latter tradition.

To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.

More in this issue

Winter 2013 (27.4) Feature

The Touch of Midas: Money, Markets, and Morality

Money, like God, injects infinity into human desires. To love it is to embark on a journey without end. Three new books testify to money’...

Winter 2013 (27.4) Review

Special Responsibilities: Global Problems and American Power by Mlada Bukovansky, Ian Clark, Robyn Eckersley, Richard Price, Christian Reus-Smit, and Nicholas Wheeler

Claims for "special responsibilities" are sometimes made to rally domestic support for some costly international action, or to exempt a great power from norms that ...

Winter 2013 (27.4) Essay

Ad Fontes: The Question of Rebellion and Moral Tradition on the Use of Force

JAMES TURNER JOHNSON On the older conception, the sovereign could use force against behavior that he understood as endangering the order, justice, and peace of ...