Spring 2008 (22.1) Essay

On the Morality of Immigration

My goal here is twofold: First, I wish to make a plea for the relevance of moral considerations in debates about immigration. Too often, immigration debates are conducted solely from the standpoint of "what is good for us," without regard for the justifiability of immigration policies to those excluded. Second, I wish to offer a standpoint that demonstrates why one should think of immigration as a moral problem that must be considered in the context of global justice. More specifically, I will argue that the earth belongs to humanity in common and that this matters for assessing immigration policy. The case I will be particularly interested in is immigration into the United States, where immigration policy continues to be a hotly debated topic. However, that discussion takes the form of a case study: the relevant considerations apply generally.

To read or purchase the full text, click here.

More in this issue

Spring 2008 (22.1) Feature

Deliberation and Global Governance: Liberal, Cosmopolitan, and Critical Perspectives

This paper develops a critical analysis of deliberative approaches to global governance. After first defining global governance and with a minimalist conception of deliberation in ...

Spring 2008 (22.1) Feature

Justifications of the Iraq War Examined

This paper critically assesses three claims on behalf of the Iraq war made by the Bush administration and by various defenders of the war. Then ...

Spring 2008 (22.1) Review

The Clash Within: Religion, Violence, and India's Future by Martha C. Nussbaum

Nussbaum argues that her contribution is as that of a loudspeaker, since she feels that Indian developments are wrongly ignored in the United States and ...