Broad comparisons of international relations across time—of the prospects for peace and of the possibilities for a new ethics for a connected world—typically focus on two dimensions: economic globalization and integration on the one hand, and the character of major interstate relations on the other. One of the most striking features of the pre-1914 world was precisely the coincidence of intensified globalization with a dramatic deterioration in major power relations, the downfall of concert-style approaches to international order, and the descent into total war and ideological confrontation—what T. S. Eliot termed “the panorama of futility and anarchy which is contemporary history.” Today’s optimists stress the degree to which globalization appears much more firmly institutionalized than it was a hundred years ago, the rather striking success of global economic governance in responding to the financial crisis of 2007–2008 (compared to, say, the Great Depression), and the longer-term trend within international society to move away from major-power war. Pessimists are less sure. They worry that we have had to re-learn just how unstable global capitalism can be, both in terms of the wrenching societal changes produced by economic success and of the political strains produced by slowdown and recession. And they point to the abiding or resurgent power of nationalism in all of the core countries in the system, the return of balance-of-power thinking (above all in Asia), and the renewed salience of major power politics. This article focuses on a third dimension—the decline of Western dominance.
To read or purchase the full text of this article, click here.
More in this issue
Summer 2013 (27.2) • Essay
Building Common Ground: Going Beyond the Liberal Conundrum
To stay viable as a political ideology, liberalism needs to show that it can remain true to its universal norms while being responsive to cultural ...
![](https://cdn.carnegiecouncil.org/media/eia/_900x525_crop_center-center_none_ns/featured-image-liberal-leviathon.jpg?v=1721248892)
Summer 2013 (27.2) • Review
Liberal Leviathan: The Origins, Crisis, and Transformation of the American World Order by G. John Ikenberry
REVIEW BY DANIEL DEUDNEY This book masterfully draws on history, advances international relations theory, and illuminates foreign policy choices.
Summer 2013 (27.2) • Feature
Concepts of Peace: From 1913 to the Present
The Great War and its imagery imprinted itself on the human imagination. In poetry and prose, photography, art, film, and other modes of expression, its ...