Fall 2018 (32.3) Essay

The Ethics of Countering Digital Propaganda

Abstract: How can a state react to being a target of disinformation activities by another state without losing the moral ground that it seeks to protect? This essay argues that the concept of moral authority offers an original framework for addressing this dilemma. As a power resource, moral authority enables an actor to have its arguments treated with priority by others and to build support for its actions, but only as long as its behavior does not deviate from certain moral expectations. To develop moral authority, an actor engaged in combating digital propaganda must cultivate six normative attributes: truthfulness and prudence for demonstrating the nature of the harmful effects of disinformation; accountability, integrity, and effectiveness for establishing the normative standing of the actor to engage in counter-intervention; and responsibility for confirming the proportionality of the response.

Keywords: digital propaganda, disinformation, ethics, moral authority, hybrid warfare

The full essay is available to subscribers only. Click here for access.

More in this issue

Fall 2018 (32.3) Essay

Covert Positive Incentives as an Alternative to War

In this essay, James Pattison argues that covert positive incentives are preferable to both overt incentives and covert force.

Fall 2018 (32.3) Review

Conflict-Related Violence Against Women: Transforming Transition, by Aisling Swaine

The overarching aim of Aisling Swaine’s recent book is to empirically and theoretically expand our understanding of conflict-related violence against women. The breadth and ...

Fall 2018 (32.3) Essay

Ending Atrocity Crimes: The False Promise of Fatalism

Some commentators suggest that the best way to minimize harm in atrocity situations is to let the state win as quickly as possible. Could this ...